"The French left has this fantastic idea that anyone who does not share exactly their ideas is illegitimate, he said. We have debates and if I am not in agreement with them, I am brutal… I am a danger for democracy for the sole reason that I do not have leftwing ideas…"
And that is more or less what he was conscious of last night. Aware that the socialists have little by way of substance but are keen to attack his bruiser reputation he approached the debate too cautiously and let her get the upper hand. Not in a rabid way though. She just got far too much vacuous verbage in there. 
The debate was dominated by the economy, youth, unemployment, violence, immigration and the EU. But both sides pretty much played it safe – neither will be picking up many votes from centre’s undecided voters. Sego put Sarko on the backfoot simply because he was far too inclined to be the gentleman in order to avoid this Bruiser reputation.
Apart from the one emotional (rather than rabid) spat about education for the handicapped – paraphrased in Dees post below, she merely presented her tax-and-spend policies for change on the table which Sarko then summarily crushed. In summary: “That’s a stunning piece of detail. Can’t you give us a figure?” enquires Mr Sarkozy. Ms Royal: “No, I can’t.”
Bear in mind that the elegant Ms Royal has made it to the top of a political arena that has not seen many women make it so far. She wouldnt have made it if she hadnt been pretty, mind you. As such she has to manage this and still come across as intelligent and credible – she hasnt done half badly. She isnt by any means incapable of this task. Her own party of Big Swinging Dick Socialists seemed incapable of accepting her as a leader so she has had to fight her corner more than once. Last night she came across as determined and genuine but waffly, emotional and socialist status quo. Maybe thats to Sarkos advantage in the end – hard to tell. She was mostly dogding the difficult questions and changing the subject all the time – her sums as he showed simply didnt add up.
That said albeit a quieter image-wary Mr Sarkozy, he didnt try to ingratiate himself with the French public as much as id expected when it came to his policies. He laid his plans for the economy on the table and the French will, if they vote him in, be voting in change. His ideas for the 35 hour working week are clever – he plans to sidestep the socialist stalemate that transfixes the ouvriers by increasing buying power – work more hours, dont pay additional taxes. He alluded to the success of the UK in terms of economy – whilst she preferred the Scandi models.
Paraphrasing: Sarkozy maintains that France cant continue to ‘welcome the world’ and will need to manage immigration properly – there will be no Papers amnesty if he comes to power and he will be tough on immigration generally- the opposite to Sego.
On the issue of Turkey and the EU the word ‘islamism’ crept in. Sarkozy made it very clear that he would fight to keep Turkey out. Paraphrasing again: they are not European, we do not need Europes borders closer to Iran and Iraq, their government is unstable and we dont need the islamism. I will fight to keep them out (emphatic on this point if not the rest of the EU question – compared with Sego, Blair and Bush who would prefer to wait and then let them in)
The polls indicate the debate hasnt affected the swing either way. The Right still see Sarko as the policy and change ‘Master’ and the Left see Sego as the Batailleuse. My local newsagent (who is of course pretty unrepresentative of all but loves his politics nonetheless!) thinks Sarko will make France more competitive and that Sego doesnt have it in her to be a President on policy alone. Whatver – he was keen to make sure Troll knows that Chirac was un grand voleur.
At the moment my preference is 100% for Sarko Sarko Sarko, my money however would be on Segelene. She came across pretty well. If Sarko fails on Sunday i wondered about inviting hin to the UK. Im sure there is some piece of EU bureacracy that could help out there.
Blair on Sarko in Paris Match (French magazine) today: “You tell me that there are those who call Sarkozy the new Blair. Poor man. Thats a heavy burden to carry”